Published on Monday, May 24 2010
I was let down by the sixth season of LOST. This is in large part due to the knowledge that the show would end with this season. The number of ongoing questions and unresolved plot holes was an asset to LOST as it provided motivation to continue watching. People hoped that whatever they cared about most would be answered in this season. To me, this season was supposed to wrap up everything presented in the past five seasons. I had this expectation because I knew it was the last season.
The season did accomplish this to some extent and provided a few spectacular episodes (specifically Ab Aeterno and Across the Sea) however, as a whole I felt let down by it. As the season progressed I was fed up with the alternative time line. The writer’s condemned calling it an alternative time line as they saw it to be of equal importance, however, with the season concluded I think it is perfectly fair to address it as such. The reason I never cared about the alt time was that there was no point. I had no interest in watching what life could have been like. Any show can do that. I wouldn’t watch a Friends spin off in which none of the characters knew each other but still were neighbors. The alt timeline provided one thing as far as I can see and that is to be able to resolve a long (1 season) running issue at the end of the show. To be able to present something we didn’t see coming and had almost no hints to at the very end is keeping with LOST’s paradigm and provides some closure. However, this closure did not leave me saying, “Ah, what a nice resolution, I never thought of it that way!” Instead is played off an argument long running throughout the show, which is the question as to whether or not everyone was dead. Even that is too much credit though; they simply concluded a plot device that I didn’t like in the first place. I feel some satisfaction as they have allowed me to be justified in not liking the alt time line yet at the same time I am let down because I wanted it to be so important.
If the alt time line had taken up two episodes or maybe even three, it would have been justified to me. Instead they focused less effort on a more central issue, the light. The “heart of the island” a plot device seemingly the most central to the entire show was given three episodes instead of season.
That being said there are some things that I thought were done spectacularly. The conflict between Man in Black and Jacob was spectacular. I was pleasantly reminded by some research on Lostpedia that MIB appeared in the very first episode of the show as the smoke monster. His story arc is indicative of what I wanted from this entire season. Jacob is first mentioned in season 2 and becomes a central character and thus seeing his back story is something that we have had to wait for longer than almost any other character. Richard Alpert first appears in season three and also plays a key role in the show. These three characters are the longest lasting characters on the island and as such provide not only character based conflict and interest but also are the instigators of the vast majority of the mythology regarding the island. Thus I was so happy and ready to enjoy flashback episodes regarding each of them. They were well told, emotional, and provided answers to long running questions-thus establishing a basis with which to book end all the story lines we previously encountered.
We learned about the candidacy of each of our main protagonists, the light on the island, the lighthouse. We got wonderful character development or at least pleasant inclusion for Desmond, Widmore, Ben, Jack, Hurley, and probably some other people I am forgetting. Sadly, for me, this was not enough to temper the alternate time line which to me provided only an opportunity for Sawyer and Juliette to get back together and for Desmond to run around being cool.
Despite this, I am prompted to give thought towards our alternate time line. It is purgatory. An amusing inclusion or self referencing fan indulgence keeping with the “we are all dead” train of thought, as many people speculated that this is what the island was all along. It is a place for everyone who dies (or maybe only island related people) to exist until they are ready to “leave,” presumably to heaven, as we definitely didn’t see mister man in black there. A key factor in my interpretation as such is the encounter between Desmond and Eloise at the concert. Eloise tells Desmond that she told him to stop all this and Desmond says he knows but was doing it anyway. To this Eloise asks “are you going to take my son” and Desmond replies “not with me” or something to that extent. So while Eloise’s son (Daniel Widmore/Faraday) has been dead longer than Eloise or almost any other character on the show, he is not yet ready to pass on to the after life presumably because he hasn’t yet realized his necessary connection to Charlotte or something. This conclusion does not really resolve the issue of why Eloise seems to be aware that this land is purgatory but yet she does not pass on. My own resolution is that maybe this purgatory and the island purgatory (Where Michael is/the voices) are magically/religiously connected and she is someone who can’t pass on for some reason, like murdering her son.
While I enjoy the self referencing one liners –Ben: “I have answers” Locke: “What is the black smoke” or Richard: “I’ve known something for a long time, we’re all dead, this place is death” or Flocke: “Don’t you seem like the obvious choice” to Jack; this entire story arc felt like a self referencing creation that the writer’s decided to make up after realizing what a good idea the fans had to have the entire show be in purgatory.
I can forgive all the things that the show didn’t address, as surely there are far too many of them. I can kind of forgive their creations just for this season (the temple) as they mostly served a purpose (such as explaining the light and dark in all of us/how smokey possesses people etc.) I find it harder to forgive them for using such precious little time to create a plot device that allows them to just do whatever they want because it’s all fake.
While I hate on the season as a whole a bit, I did enjoy this final episode and have put more time into this show than most endeavors in my life. I am happy to have been a part of such a significant pop-culture event and have enjoyed every minute of discussing, thinking about, and watching this show.